---
description: Quickly find and compare the leading Square Payroll vs OnPay alternatives. Comprehensive listing of competitors & similar tools for fast software selection and to contact several providers directly.
image: https://gdm-localsites-assets-gfprod.imgix.net/images/getapp/og_logo-94fd2a03a6c7a0e54fc0c9e21a1c0ce9.png
title: Compare Square Payroll vs OnPay | GetApp Canada 2026
---

Breadcrumb: [Home](/) > [Human Resources Software](/directory/256/human-resources/software) > [Square Payroll \<span\>vs\</span\> OnPay](https://www.getapp.ca/compare/105309/110713/square-payroll/vs/onpay)

# Compare Square Payroll vs OnPay

Canonical: https://www.getapp.ca/compare/105309/110713/square-payroll/vs/onpay

> Detailed comparison between Square Payroll and OnPay. Check ratings, reviews, pricing, and features to make the best decision for your business.

-----

## At a Glance

| Metric | Square Payroll | OnPay |
| **Overall rating** | 4.7/5 | 4.8/5 |
| **Total Reviews** | 621 | 465 |
| **Starting Price** | US$35.00 | US$49.00 |
| **Free Trial** | Yes | Yes |
| **Free Version** | No | No |
| **Deployment** | Cloud, SaaS, Web-based, Android (Mobile), iPhone (Mobile), iPad (Mobile) | Cloud, SaaS, Web-based |
| **Support** | Email/Help Desk, FAQs/Forum, Knowledge Base Software, Phone Support, Chat | Email/Help Desk, FAQs/Forum, Knowledge Base Software, Phone Support, Chat |
| **Training Software** | - | Live Online, Webinars, Documentation, Videos |

## Key features

### Square Payroll

- Accounting Integration
- Benefits Dashboard
- Benefits Management
- Customizable Reports
- Direct Deposit
- Employee Management
- Employee Portal
- Employee Profiles
- Employee Self Service
- For Accountants
- For Small Businesses
- Payroll Management
- Real-Time Reporting
- Reminders
- Reporting/Analytics
- Tax Calculation
- Tax Filing
- W-2 Preparation
- Wage Garnishment
- Web-based Deployment

### OnPay

- Accounting Integration
- Benefits Dashboard
- Benefits Management
- Customizable Reports
- Direct Deposit
- Employee Management
- Employee Portal
- Employee Profiles
- Employee Self Service
- For Accountants
- For Small Businesses
- Payroll Management
- Real-Time Reporting
- Reminders
- Reporting/Analytics
- Tax Calculation
- Tax Filing
- W-2 Preparation
- Wage Garnishment
- Web-based Deployment

## Links

- [View Square Payroll Profile](https://www.getapp.ca/software/105309/square-payroll)
- [View OnPay Profile](https://www.getapp.ca/software/110713/onpay)
- [View Original Comparison](https://www.getapp.ca/compare/105309/110713/square-payroll/vs/onpay)

-----

## Structured Data

<script type="application/ld+json">
  {"@context":"https://schema.org","@graph":[{"name":"Compare Square Payroll vs OnPay | GetApp Canada 2026","description":"Quickly find and compare the leading Square Payroll vs OnPay alternatives. Comprehensive listing of competitors & similar tools for fast software selection and to contact several providers directly.","url":"https://www.getapp.ca/compare/105309/110713/square-payroll/vs/onpay","about":[{"@id":"https://www.getapp.ca/software/105309/square-payroll#software"},{"@id":"https://www.getapp.ca/software/110713/onpay#software"}],"breadcrumb":{"@id":"https://www.getapp.ca/compare/105309/110713/square-payroll/vs/onpay#breadcrumblist"},"@type":["WebPage","CollectionPage"],"@id":"https://www.getapp.ca/compare/105309/110713/square-payroll/vs/onpay#webpage","publisher":{"@id":"https://www.getapp.ca/#organization"},"inLanguage":"en-CA","isPartOf":{"@id":"https://www.getapp.ca/#website"}},{"name":"Square Payroll","description":"Square Payroll is an integrated online payroll processing solution that helps SMBs and enterprises manage the paychecks of both salaried and hourly wage employees. The software offers various features including integrated timecards, tax calculators and new-hire reporting.\n\nSquare Payroll offers a dashboard that can be accessed by all the employees to update their personal information, bank account details and tax withholdings. Access rights to this information are controlled by the administrator to ensure that the employees can view and edit only their details. The timecard feature helps to track employee clock-in and out and to calculate overtime, bonus payments and commissions. Managers can also review, edit and manage the timecard information by using the dashboard functionality. \n\nSquare Payroll also tracks employee leave balances and calculates the accruals for each employee on the basis of the leave policies set by the employer. The application allows managers to set unique paid time off (PTO) policy for each employee and ensures the payouts whenever an employee avails them.The software integrates with ADP, Intuit and Paychex to pull out an employee's payroll reports with a previous company and ensures a smooth transition to Square Payroll systems. The tool also helps users to complete tax forms and adhere to the guidelines set by the state payroll tax agencies. \n\nThe solution is currently available in twelve states in the U.S. and adheres to the PCI Data Security Standard for card processing and provides layered security.","image":"https://gdm-catalog-fmapi-prod.imgix.net/ProductScreenshot/d7e91eca-9525-4186-a2e0-39edf9a54c59.png","url":"https://www.getapp.ca/software/105309/square-payroll","@type":"SoftwareApplication","@id":"https://www.getapp.ca/software/105309/square-payroll#software","applicationCategory":"BusinessApplication","publisher":{"@id":"https://www.getapp.ca/#organization"},"aggregateRating":{"@type":"AggregateRating","bestRating":5,"ratingCount":621,"ratingValue":4.7},"offers":{"price":"35","@type":"Offer","priceCurrency":"USD"},"operatingSystem":"Cloud, Android, Platform ios, Platform ipad"},{"name":"OnPay","description":"OnPay’s payroll and HR software helps run payroll, automate quarterly and year-end tax filings, streamline HR processes, manage employee benefits, and more. The platform integrates with third-party tools such as QuickBooks, Xero, and time-tracking software\n\nThe payroll module facilitates payments to employees and contractors while handling calculations, deductions, and tax filings. The HR capabilities automate onboarding, PTO tracking, and organization chart management, while providing HR guidance and access to insurance options.","image":"https://gdm-catalog-fmapi-prod.imgix.net/ProductScreenshot/8e5a75ee-982d-4e32-bb35-24c789ccbe32.png","url":"https://www.getapp.ca/software/110713/onpay","@type":"SoftwareApplication","@id":"https://www.getapp.ca/software/110713/onpay#software","applicationCategory":"BusinessApplication","publisher":{"@id":"https://www.getapp.ca/#organization"},"aggregateRating":{"@type":"AggregateRating","bestRating":5,"ratingCount":465,"ratingValue":4.8},"offers":{"price":"49","@type":"Offer","priceCurrency":"USD"},"operatingSystem":"Cloud"},{"@type":"BreadcrumbList","itemListElement":[{"name":"Home","position":1,"item":"/","@type":"ListItem"},{"name":"Human Resources Software","position":2,"item":"/directory/256/human-resources/software","@type":"ListItem"},{"name":"Square Payroll vs OnPay","position":3,"item":"https://www.getapp.ca/compare/105309/110713/square-payroll/vs/onpay","@type":"ListItem"}],"@id":"https://www.getapp.ca/compare/105309/110713/square-payroll/vs/onpay#breadcrumblist"}]}
</script>